| [00:00] Gabriel Kral at goalie for Muskingum. |
| [00:00] Callum Appleby at goalie for Bethany. |
| Corner kick by MUS Gage Toy [02:50]. |
| [03:32] Shot by BET Jose Arzate, SAVE TEAM. |
| [03:37] Shot by BET Jack Waters HIGH. |
| [04:14] Offside against Muskingum. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| Corner kick by BET Jack Waters [11:55]. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [15:45] Shot by MUS William Debolt HIGH. |
| [16:32] Shot by BET Jack Waters, SAVE TEAM. |
| [16:39] Shot by BET Jay O'Donnell, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| [17:07] Offside against Muskingum. |
| [18:29] Offside against Muskingum. |
| [19:49] BET substitution: Javier Betancourt for Marlon Mejia. |
| [21:50] Shot by BET Adam Franco HIGH. |
| [22:02] MUS substitution: Zach Schmauch for Chris Aboagye. |
| [22:02] MUS substitution: Trent Newby for Logan Lazar. |
| [23:31] Offside against Bethany. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [25:32] MUS substitution: Jace Morris for Trent Newby. |
| [25:32] BET substitution: Anthony Bradden for Ian Hayhurst. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [26:19] MUS substitution: Trent Newby for Jace Morris. |
| [26:19] BET substitution: Ian Hayhurst for B Sellah-Mohammed. |
| [26:48] Shot by MUS Gage Toy, SAVE Callum Appleby. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| Corner kick by MUS Gage Toy [29:02]. |
| [29:16] Header Shot by MUS Nick Koch WIDE. |
| [31:23] BET substitution: AJ Wahlie for Jose Arzate. |
| [32:13] Offside against Muskingum. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [35:04] MUS substitution: Mitchell Corey for Alex Furst. |
| [35:37] Offside against Muskingum. |
| [38:50] Shot by BET Kai Whitney, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| [39:12] MUS substitution: Jace Morris for Zach Schmauch. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [40:46] Offside against Muskingum. |
| [41:40] Shot by BET Anthony Bradden WIDE. |
| [42:24] Shot by MUS Trent Newby, SAVE Callum Appleby. |
| [42:49] Shot by BET Kai Whitney, SAVE TEAM. |
| [43:24] Offside against Muskingum. |
| [43:49] Shot by BET Kai Whitney WIDE. |
| End of period [45:00]. |
| Start of 2nd period [45:00]. |
| For BET: #10 Jack Waters, #9 Javier Betancourt, #11 Jose Arzate, #23 AJ Wahlie, #6 Jay O'Donnell, #5 Daniel Booth, #3 Jose Saldivar, #22 Kai Whitney, #20 Ian Hayhurst, #01 Callum Appleby, #12 Adam Franco. |
| For MUS: #11 Gage Toy, #13 Mitchell Corey, #8 Corbin Salyer, #22 Drew Wise, #6 William Debolt, #19 Barrett Fitzgerald, #23 Chris Aboagye, #15 Nick Koch, #00 Gabriel Kral, #4 Logan Lazar, #21 Amier Salah. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| [46:47] Header Shot by MUS Mitchell Corey WIDE. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| [49:49] Shot by BET Kai Whitney WIDE. |
| [51:46] Yellow card on MUS Logan Lazar. |
| [52:06] MUS substitution: Trent Newby for Logan Lazar. |
| [52:51] Offside against Bethany. |
| [53:57] Shot by BET Javier Betancourt HIGH. |
| [58:38] Shot by BET Jose Arzate, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| [60:13] MUS substitution: Jace Morris for Nick Koch. |
| [60:13] BET substitution: B Sellah-Mohammed for Jose Arzate. |
| [61:40] Shot by BET Kai Whitney HIGH. |
| [61:46] MUS substitution: Alex Furst for Mitchell Corey. |
| [61:46] MUS substitution: Zach Schmauch for Chris Aboagye. |
| [62:28] Header Shot by BET B Sellah-Mohammed, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| [64:34] Shot by BET Jack Waters WIDE. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [65:26] Shot by MUS Alex Furst WIDE. |
| [68:50] MUS substitution: Nick Koch for Jace Morris. |
| For MUS: #11 Gage Toy, #22 Drew Wise, #19 Barrett Fitzgerald, #6 William Debolt, #21 Amier Salah, #00 Gabriel Kral, #15 Nick Koch, #12 Zach Schmauch, #16 Trent Newby, #5 Alex Furst, #8 Corbin Salyer. |
| [70:19] Shot by MUS Alex Furst, SAVE TEAM. |
| [73:56] Shot by BET Adam Franco, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| [74:29] Shot by BET Jose Saldivar HIGH. |
| [75:39] GOAL by BET Jay O'Donnell (FIRST GOAL), Assist by Adam Franco, goal number 1 for season. |
| Bethany 1, Muskingum 0 |
| *Took pass from left 6 yd box; netted in top left corner. |
| [76:30] Shot by BET Kai Whitney, SAVE TEAM. |
| Corner kick by BET Jack Waters [77:01]. |
| Corner kick by BET Jack Waters [77:20]. |
| [77:28] Header Shot by BET Javier Betancourt, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| [78:19] GOAL by MUS Zach Schmauch, Assist by Gage Toy. |
| Muskingum 1, Bethany 1 |
| *Breakaway; pass from left side; finished. |
| [78:19] Yellow card on BET Callum Appleby. |
| [80:43] MUS substitution: Jace Morris for Amier Salah. |
| [80:43] BET substitution: Jose Arzate for B Sellah-Mohammed. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| Corner kick by BET Jack Waters [81:31]. |
| [82:28] Offside against Bethany. |
| [83:26] Shot by BET Jack Waters WIDE. |
| [83:58] Yellow card on MUS Zach Schmauch. |
| [85:23] MUS substitution: Chris Aboagye for Zach Schmauch. |
| [85:23] MUS substitution: Mitchell Corey for Nick Koch. |
| Corner kick by BET Jack Waters [87:11]. |
| [87:19] Header Shot by BET Jose Saldivar HIT POST. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| End of period [90:00]. |
| Start of OT period [90:00]. |
| For BET: #6 Jay O'Donnell, #11 Jose Arzate, #23 AJ Wahlie, #22 Kai Whitney, #20 Ian Hayhurst, #3 Jose Saldivar, #01 Callum Appleby, #12 Adam Franco, #5 Daniel Booth, #10 Jack Waters, #9 Javier Betancourt. |
| For MUS: #6 William Debolt, #24 Jace Morris, #23 Chris Aboagye, #5 Alex Furst, #00 Gabriel Kral, #11 Gage Toy, #8 Corbin Salyer, #19 Barrett Fitzgerald, #15 Nick Koch, #22 Drew Wise, #16 Trent Newby. |
| [91:17] Shot by BET Jack Waters HIT POST. |
| Foul on Bethany. |
| [94:06] Shot by MUS Gage Toy WIDE. |
| [94:46] Shot by MUS Gage Toy, SAVE Callum Appleby. |
| [95:20] Shot by BET Jack Waters, SAVE TEAM. |
| Corner kick by BET Jack Waters [95:47]. |
| Corner kick by BET Adam Franco [96:08]. |
| [96:16] Header Shot by BET Daniel Booth, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| [96:51] Shot by BET Jack Waters, SAVE Gabriel Kral. |
| Corner kick by MUS Gage Toy [98:39]. |
| End of period [100:00]. |
| Start of OT2 period [100:00]. |
| For BET: #6 Jay O'Donnell, #23 AJ Wahlie, #22 Kai Whitney, #11 Jose Arzate, #3 Jose Saldivar, #20 Ian Hayhurst, #12 Adam Franco, #5 Daniel Booth, #01 Callum Appleby, #10 Jack Waters, #9 Javier Betancourt. |
| For MUS: #6 William Debolt, #24 Jace Morris, #4 Logan Lazar, #5 Alex Furst, #00 Gabriel Kral, #11 Gage Toy, #8 Corbin Salyer, #19 Barrett Fitzgerald, #15 Nick Koch, #12 Zach Schmauch, #22 Drew Wise. |
| Corner kick by MUS Gage Toy [103:01]. |
| [104:03] Header Shot by MUS Logan Lazar WIDE. |
| Foul on Muskingum. |
| [107:04] Offside against Bethany. |
| End of period [110:00]. |
| Muskingum 1, Bethany 1 |