| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 20, 2016 | Philadelphia, Pa. | Salisbury 52, Carnegie Mellon 20 | Box score |
| Nov 19, 2016 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Wittenberg 33, Thomas More 30 | Box score |
| Nov 19, 2016 | Philadelphia, Pa. | Westminster 33, Utica 6 | Box score |
| Nov 18, 2016 | Philadelphia, Pa. | W&J 38, Brockport 31 | Box score |
| Nov 12, 2016 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Westminster 24, Geneva 0 | Box score |
| Nov 12, 2016 | Grove City, Pa. | Thiel 47, Grove City 41 | Box score |
| Nov 12, 2016 | Cleveland, Ohio | Carnegie Mellon 26, Case Western Reserve 21 | Box score |
| Nov 12, 2016 | Waynesburg, Pa. | W&J 14, Waynesburg 10 | Box score |
| Nov 12, 2016 | Bethany, W.Va. | Bethany 32, Saint Vincent 31 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | Latrobe, Pa. | Saint Vincent 30, Waynesburg 12 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | Chicago, Ill. | Carnegie Mellon 37, Chicago 24 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | Bethany, W.Va. | Bethany 33, Grove City 14 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | Greenville, Pa. | Thomas More 63, Thiel 16 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Case Western Reserve 26, Westminster 22 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | Washington, Pa. | W&J 17, Geneva 7 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | Greenville, Pa. | Thiel 50, Waynesburg 42 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Geneva 21, Grove City 14 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | St. Louis, Mo. | Case Western Reserve 56, Washington (Mo.) 38 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | Washington, Pa. | W&J 48, Saint Vincent 26 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 35, Westminster 23 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 30, Bethany 7 | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2016 | Cleveland, Ohio | Case Western Reserve 16, Geneva 14 | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2016 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 49, Thiel 33 | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2016 | Latrobe, Pa. | Thomas More 45, Saint Vincent 14 | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2016 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 16, W&J 10 | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2016 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 29, Geneva 10 | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2016 | Washington, Pa. | W&J 37, Bethany 36 | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2016 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Thomas More 40, Waynesburg 7 | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2016 | Grove City, Pa. | Westminster 52, Grove City 23 | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2016 | Cleveland, Ohio | Case Western Reserve 48, Thiel 21 | Box score |
| Oct 08, 2016 | Washington, Pa. | W&J 55, Carnegie Mellon 52 | Box score |
| Oct 08, 2016 | Bethany, W.Va. | Case Western Reserve 37, Bethany 14 | Box score |
| Oct 08, 2016 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 10, Geneva 9 | Box score |
| Oct 08, 2016 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 37, Saint Vincent 22 | Box score |
| Oct 08, 2016 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 70, Grove City 20 | Box score |
| Oct 01, 2016 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 49, Bethany 26 | Box score |
| Oct 01, 2016 | Cleveland, Ohio | Case Western Reserve 53, Saint Vincent 28 | Box score |
| Oct 01, 2016 | Greenville, Pa. | W&J 62, Thiel 14 | Box score |
| Oct 01, 2016 | Grove City, Pa. | Waynesburg 14, Grove City 10 | Box score |
| Oct 01, 2016 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Thomas More 45, Westminster 35 | Box score |
| Sep 24, 2016 | Bethany, W.Va. | Westminster 38, Bethany 9 | Box score |
| Sep 24, 2016 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Geneva 35, Thiel 27 | Box score |
| Sep 24, 2016 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Case Western Reserve 35, Waynesburg 7 | Box score |
| Sep 24, 2016 | Latrobe, Pa. | Saint Vincent 57, Grove City 32 | Box score |
| Sep 24, 2016 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 20, Carnegie Mellon 16 | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2016 | Grove City, Pa. | Case Western Reserve 55, Grove City 0 | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2016 | Greenville, Pa. | Thiel 57, Bethany 47 | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2016 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 35, Waynesburg 23 | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2016 | Latrobe, Pa. | Saint Vincent 28, Geneva 21 | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2016 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 35, W&J 9 | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2016 | Greenville, Pa. | Saint Vincent 32, Thiel 30 | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2016 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Geneva 21, Bethany 0 | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2016 | Washington, Pa. | W&J 65, Grove City 13 | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2016 | Bridgewater, Va. | Thomas More 41, Bridgewater 17 | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2016 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 28, Waynesburg 7 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 40, Hiram 0 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Franklin, Ind. | Franklin 43, Thomas More 39 | Box score |
| Sept 3, 2016 | Frostburg, Md. | Frostburg State 31, Geneva 10 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Meadville, Pa. | Thiel 44, Allegheny 21 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Waynesburg, Pa | Muskingum 17, Waynesburg 16 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Alma, Mich. | Saint Vincent 47, Alma 24 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Grove City, Pa. | Juniata 31, Grove City 26 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Washington, Pa. | W&J 58, Wooster 20 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Cleveland, Ohio | Case Western Reserve 45, Chicago 17 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Bethany, W.Va. | Bethany 23, Ursinus 13 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Washington (Mo.) 41, Carnegie Mellon 34 | Box score |